Pinkamena

Love this game, have been playing it since it first came out. I hope updates to this are still coming, because there is a lot of potential here. One little thing I would tweak. When playing on Make it Personal mode, if given Bodyguard. If you Bodyguard the to protect against the final attack and are successful. It should say something like you will always be remembered for the town you gave your life to protect, or something like that. :P

Still in development yet already so addicting! I happened to come across this randomly and wondered what it was. When I began to play I was immediately nervous. Im kind of scared and then I just end up falling in love with the game. Love the quirky pony names that are chosen at random and I also love the create your pony thingy majig. Cannot wait to see what this game turns into for future updates!

So I've played mafia before and have been searching for an app that might suffice and this app really does a great job of remaking the game while featuring ponies (?) as town citizens instead. I understand this is still quite new and there are going to be plenty of updates in the future, but perhaps a bit of instruction on how the game works would be nice? The app literally just tosses you in with a small introduction. It's a small thing, but it really would help.

True to its claims, "Pinkamena" bears all of the qualities that make games like "Mafia" and "Town of Salem" so enticing and intriguing. There are a couple of features I'd like to see implemented, such as the option to play as a villain in Single Player, but these things may come in due time. The recent addition of custom ponies can make the game feel more personal, and is another great touch on an already very fun game.

There are definately bugs that need fixing. Some parts of ponies and other selection borders randomly disappear, there have been several times that a particular pony will end up dead when there is no record of them being killed, sometimes ponies that are not dead will not be able to use their abilities due to buttons not appearing. This last bug happens especially with the Nurse. Sometimes I also get reports from ponies that I have sent out, but died in the night (not sure if that's a bug or not)

I love this game! I think the concept is unique and fun. The graphics go well with the mysterious tone of the game, and the music is pretty good. My only problem is that it's a little glitchy, as the game prevented me from sending my ponies after someone who I suspected guilty. There's also a glitch, and as far as I can tell, if a pony or their background turns invisible, they're Pinkamena or a Changeling. A few bugs, but overall, a good game!

This game has cool mechanics and a very unique style. I love how you are in control but not at the same time. My only problem is that there should probably be a tutorial... my first time playing I was really confused, and even thought that you were assigning jobs, and the one it was assigned to was random! So, ya... a tutorial might be nice...

When I saw this I didn't know what to expect. God, I expected to freak out! But it turns out that I love this game! I can't put it down! I think it would be really cool if you named certain custom ponies it would trigger an easter egg e.g. naming one pinkie pie increasing the chance of her being pinkamena.

Alright first off, I really love this game ^_^ its very addictive and the music is fantastic. However, you should update the info in the roles description page with your updates. Stuff like how the the Jailor talks about people attacking his charges, how the Consort kills when the queen is gone, stuff like that. My only other request would be gender customization for ponies, but I understand why not since thats alot of text to edit. "EDIT: found an invincible pair :P

I'm so glad I decided to give this game a try. I am borderline obsessed. If you're looking for a smart game with a fantastic, creepy atmosphere then LOOK NO FURTHER. I've spent countless hours investigating this and deducing that. If you want to be a detective, play this game. If you want grimdark ponies, play this game. If you want to be hacked to pieces in the middle of the night, play this game. Updates are rolling out all the time, each better than the last. ✔✔✔

"I wonder who it is... Is it the one with no mane?" It seems that sometimes a achangeling/Queen/Pinkamena will lose something whether it is the Mane, Coat, Iris, or even the possibility to assign a role to them. Overall, its steadily increasing in Better quality. Hopefully it will be updated again soon.

Love playing it on LAN Multiplayer (though my brothers not that much of a challenge) but the glitches are everywhere. ( I'm Using customized characters) Some deaths aren't announced like when I got a report saying the target was successfuly murdered but found out that the pony was still alive (was a Changeling). Also as a Changeling twice there would be a glitch that you could only choose the consort the first night. And there would be no reports. Reopening the app fxes it but still I love it nonetheless

It's a great game that requires strategy and well planed out actions, just what I love! You play as an investigator that was sent to a small town to solve a series of murders. It's atmospheric, dark and well thought out. I don't even watch MLP, but this is a game that I'd recommend to any strategy game lover.

I knew this genre of games from a video of Town of Salem and I really liked it. Now I can play something like that with ponies haha. Also, I wanted to report that there's an absurd amount of bugs when playing as the Changelings. You've probably been reported this several times, I know it's still in development. Anyway, I loved it, I can't wait to play online.

Holy crap, this is AMAZING!!!! So simple with minimal gameplay, yet somehow it still manages to be so hair-raisingly creepy! I love this! I love getting to try to deduce the bad guys, and it's extra jarring when the avatars of the ponies change into their affiliated bad guy character. This is a gem for any My Little Pony, murder mystery or horror fan. Fantastic work!

Love this game. Not a big pony fan, but the game is fantastic. I do have a bug to report though, with all standard settings, my changeling queen was untargetable by any actions other than lynching after the drone was killed. Her portrait in the selection screen went blank except for the picture of her and the text. Along with this, the party pony doesnt seem to get killed by Pinkamena when she visits. Thanks!

There is too much to love, thought sometimes a ponies box will dissapear, leaving the name and mane. I wont be able to do anything to the pony at that point exept execute. If that was fixed it would be a perfect game! Keep up the good work!!

I like the game, but the one thing I dislike is that its more or less luck to figure out who is who (such as figuring out who the changlings and pinkamena are), I think it could be improved if there was some way to spot them early on such as things like personality or noticing someone out at night or something. I also think it would be cool if the game was more interactive although I don't know if that could be done, looking forward to updates

Honestly, it's such a great game! But...The multiplayer mode either doesn't work or takes too long to find another person. I was waiting 5 minutes (yes, that's long for me) and still no one joined. Maybe no one was on at the time, I'm not sure.

Catfood Studios, I raise my glass, take off my hat, bow... Whatever you like! This is an awesome game. Every game is different. Sometimes the bad guys feel.. Smart! And they execute whoever you need at the moment, or even kill the pony you assigned that very night! And... Well, sometimes you just kill them all in three days and get an achievement. Anyway! 10/10, keep the updated coming ;)

Due to an error I have not been able to play past Day 6, and as I am still learning the game I haven't been able to to complete it by day 6. Otherwise, it is a really cool and well done game! Definitely very interesting so far. I hope this issue will be fixed so that I can finish it!

I thought it would be silly, but it's not. I play offline so I'm not bothered by ads, but I've paid for the ad-free version to show my support. I love the custom pony option! The bit about the hacksaw is always funny! Can't wait for Pinkamena 2!

I really love this game. Even AI can be this human-like, this is the perfect game for anyone who loves ponies and Mafia! Edit: I discovered a bug. The queen changeling can sometimes have a empty box surrounding it. Making her identified and killed. Discovered this out of curiosity.

i like it, even if the game glitches here and there. thats normal for a game. no game is going to be glitch free, the best one could do is hide the glitches and flaws with other stuff. keep up the amazing work, catfood studios!

I get that this is based off of a popular game that exists and works, but I feel like it could be made to feel less panicked and make it a little more drawn out so the game can last longer and you don't have to rely on luck as much. Also I accidentally won almost right off the start when the bodyguard killed the queen on like the second turn

I love this game its creepy and i dont recommend listening to it while playing cuz that just send shivers up my spine but i love this game ok i can understand why some ppl dont like and at times it can be annoying*cough* all the villans live *coughcough* but overall its a good game

I love creepypasta Pinkamena is my faveourite! Basicly creepypasta version of "Town Of Salem" addictive! Me and my cousin made horror game & creepypasta custom ponies! I love seeing "Tattletail's but tattoo was added to Pinkie's but tattoo outfit" pop up on the screen.

This is a really fun game, and it's always my go to thing whenever my internet connection is bad or I'm just bored. Music is great(though I wish I knew where to find it), and I honestly can't wait for 2.0 to release. Fully customisable pones are the big thing I'm wanting out of this.

In the multiplayer mode, if you turn on "make it personal" the changeling team can see who the main pony is.

An absolutely wonderful game that is challenging and rewarding all the same. Was lucky enough that the first executed pony was Pinkamena. Day 3, party pony was murdered by the changling queen while going to entertain. Ding ding, AMAZING mechanics, heh.

Good job dude! This turned out to be something much, much more greater rather then a cheap and silly fan game about MLP..but question do you plan to add remote multiplayer in the future?

Really loving the game. But my friends and I have a hard time connecting to each other via multiplayer. Instead of a "search" thing could you make it more like a lobby setup? Like most online multiplayer? That way we don't have to be connected to the same wifi network

I am trying to join a friend,but how long will it take for it to join?Is it because I have custom ponies selected?Or is it just like that?-Edit:I turned off custom ponies set and it still doesn't work.

Oh, well I'm glad it's nothing bad, I was just wondering cuz the game had messed up one of the customized ponies but all I had to do was redo the pony. Also I loved the main menu song and how it ended :)

Great but kinda easy. I slottered pinkamena on the first chance you get to execute. Then, I beat the game in two more nights.

this game sometime confuse me... Idk if it was a bug or something... example I order a reporter to look for pony and I find she innocent so I ignore it and go another but at the end when only 2left from the Evidence report I get Both is innocent? like appear to be townponies... how? it lying or what

I love the game so far! But you know how most pony ocs are unique And stuff,if you have the right tools to,could you add more and unique accessories and even possibly male ponies? If you can't do that I understand but thanks for reading this long comment,have a good day/night.

When I saw this and all the love on it I was like ok what is all the fuss about it this game but wow!I really love games like this! Oh and nice touch with the reporter because once I told them to spy on markiplier (yes I made a markiplier pony XD)they said they are a normal pony so you can't always trust them the same happened with undyne except flopped undyne was framed XD amazing game but wish you can make male characters (took a while for me to make pewds Mark and Jack and sorry that this is so lengthy)

Why not add different types of facial expressions to the ponies that way we could see if they are who the say they are. Thanks!

This is like salem town but ponyfied.I have a few suggestions:1.Make the multiplayer world wide(i want to play online so badly) 2 . Add a chat when playing online(if u have already done that then great job) 3 . if u can make it look like the actual salem town game with the houses and pets then it would actually be cooler(but if can't beacuz of copyright then its ok)and last words:I really love this game!!